Consensus at Lawyerpoint: New Philips BPDG criticism

June 11, 2002

[News]
New Philips BPDG criticism

Philips made further criticisms of BPDG in a press release issued today. The criticisms focus on the BPDG process and include charges of self-interest on the part of BPDG participants.

These criticisms seem particularly significant to us -- many of the rules were written by organizations with a direct financial interest in technologies under consideration. Therefore, as we're suggested before, their conclusions should be viewed with particular skepticism.

Philips repeated its call for a government-chartered forum with a proper process and a more broadly representative membership. Hollywood studios are likely to resist that proposal, because it might reveal the true diversity of opinion which exists among those with an interest in digital TV. In addition, end-users of digital TV might actually be represented somehow!

Posted by Seth Schoen at 05:41 PM

Join EFF!

BPDG Final Report

Summary of EFF Report on BPDG

Full EFF Report on BPDG

What is the BPDG?

In the year 2006 all over-the-air television will be digital. This is pretty hot stuff: crystal-clear pictures, ear-popping audio and interactive features for days. But as the technologists give, the studios take away.

The Broadcast Protection Discussion Group is an obscure group of Hollywood studios and technology companies that are negotiating a "consensus" for any gadget or code that can touch the studios' product. Once they're done, they want to go to Washington and ask Congress and/or the FCC to give their "standard" the force of law.

So what? Well, this is a radical departure from the way it's usually done. Usually, bright nerds invent something cool and the entertainment industry has a nervous breakdown and runs around telling everyone that the sky is falling (Marconi got sued over the radio, Sony got sued over the VCR, and it took a near miracle to get movies out of the studios' vaults and onto television). People pick up on the tech and all the interesting ways that it can be used as a creative tool, and gradually the entertainment industry realizes that a new day has dawned and gets its act together, starts shipping product for the new media, and takes home yet another squillion dollars.

This time around, the entertainment industry wants to take away all that sloppy, inefficient fooling around where technology companies try out lots of different approaches, where garage inventors go from obscurity to posterity under a hail of customers, where you and I get to invent amazing new uses for our stuff that a bunch of engineers in a board-room never would've thought of in a million years. This time around, everything not forbidden is mandatory. MORE...